The phrase traces back to 1942 when an American civil rights activist put out a pamphlet titled Speak Truth to Power: a Quaker Search for an Alternative to Violence.
Icons of the era, like Edward R. Murrow and Walter Cronkite first spoke truth to power over the radio in WWII, then on TV after the war. Cronkite’s truth about the failures in Viet Nam War triggered Johnson’s exit from the Presidency and politics. Later the Washington Post and the New York Times published the truth about Pentagon Papers and the Watergate scandal. Broadcast TV amplified that truth, and eventually truth ran Nixon out of town.
Starting in 1968 CBS’s 60 Minutes has spoken truth to power for 58 years, winning numerous awards, not to mention being the most-watched news magazine of the last six decades.
Most journalists are underpaid and overworked. But they dig up the truth anyway for a variety of reasons: It’s fun; its courgeous; it’s altruistic; it’s heroic at times; it’s never boring; and most of all, the world needs it.
Journalists witness and report parts of life unseen by the general public: rat infested slums; bloodied war zones with wounded and dead; people without heat who stuff their clothes with paper to survive the winter; police who pummel or even shoot pregnant women, children, and blacks and browns; politicians who take payoffs, and more recently; elected politicians who set records for corruption.
That’s why most journalists are liberals.
Speaking truth to power can lead to retribution, especially in the Trump era. When conservative David Ellison, son of conservative billionaire Larry Ellison, was trying to merge Paramount/Skydance with Warner Brothers for $110.9 billion, he needed the approval of FCC Chairman Brendan Carr, one of our mafia-styled President’s numerous lackeys. Trump disdains the media, recently encouraging the cancellation of Colbert’s Late Show, applauding the attempted shut down of Jimmy Kimmel, and suing CBS over a 60 Minutes interview of Kamala Harris that he didn’t like.
Carr has also recently threatened ABC’s local stations licenses. In glaring contrast to CBS caving in to Trump’s suit, ABC responded by accusing the FCC of “unconstitutional retaliation and coercion.”
Soon after Paramount (and CBS) offered to settle Trump’s suit for a total of $38 million, Carr approved the merger. Ellison then replaced Tom Cibrowski, the experienced and highly respected head of CBS news, with political conservative Bari Weis, who has none – zero – experience in broadcast news. Trump praised the move.
The result has been a precipitous drop in ratings for CBS Evening News. It now has less then half of the 8 million plus viewers of ABC Evening News.
Weis then replaced the highly respected Executive Producer of 60 Minutes, Bill Owens, with another broadcast news novice, Nick Bilton.
The Tiffany network became Trump’s Fake Gold network.
Which has led to the resignations or firings of 60 Minutes correspondents Anderson Cooper, Sharyn Alfonsi, Cecilia Vega, and Executive Producers Bill Owens, and Tanya Simon.
That’s like losing the top players and coaching staff from a Superbowl winner.
What truth did Scott Pelley speak?
Bari Weis is “…murdering 60 Minutes. She does not love this place, she was brought in to kill it and is doing exactly that”.
Her team “instructed me to inject falsehoods and bias into a politically sensitive story.”
She “has no qualifications for her job; you (Nick Bilton) have slender qualifications for this job. The changes that she’s made at the Evening News have been catastrophic, so why should we expect that any of this is going to be any better?”
Admittedly it was a bit rough of Pelley, but after 37 years at CBS News and seeing 58 years of excellence in journalism decimated by incompetence or worse, deliberation, can you blame him?
The next day Bilton fired Pelley, saying “Yesterday, you hijacked my first meeting with staff to disparage me, my qualifications, and my intentions with remarkable incivility and contempt….your employment with CBS is terminated for cause effective immediately.”
Clearly neither Bilton nor Weiss – nor Ellison – knows the history of screaming matches between one of the original 60 Minutes correspondents, Mike Wallace, and the original Executive Producer, Don Hewitt.
Speaking truth to power, especially power with political roots, doesn’t always have happy endings. On the other hand, maybe people like you and I can respond by just not watching CBS or 60 Minutes any more.
Maybe we can speak truth to power, too.